Welcome to GuzziTech.com   Guest     

Banner
 

Enter Amount:

GuzziTech.com Forum • Modern "No Start" issue solution

Modern "No Start" issue solution

Technical, non-model specific data for all new Guzzis.. post it here!

Moderators: john zibell, toddhaven, Fader

Modern "No Start" issue solution

Postby GT-Rx » Thu Jul 01, 2010 7:20 am

Thanks to Patrick Hayes/iainw & Mike H @MPHCycles.com:

Patrick Hayes' small block solution:


Image

The graphic above should explain the improvement.

Look at the relay diagram which is item #36 above. That little "P" shaped circuit on the right, fed by pins 1 and 2, is the relay's internal operating electromagnet coil. Not much work there.

Now look at the 'bridge' connection circuit fed by pins 3 an 5. When the electromagnet is energized, it pulls that "T" shaped device against the two internal connectors and bridges or 'makes' the connection. Pin 3 now feeds electrons out to your starter solenoid. The electrons come in via pin 5. But, that pin 5 source does several other things as well and has to pass through numerous connector blocks before getting here. We loose a little bit of power at every connector. Eventually, even though we still supply 12 volts to the solenoid, we no longer provide enough amperage to actually throw the heavy electromagnet in the solenoid. Thus, all we get is the 'click' of the relay itself.

If we simply provide a direct circuit from the battery into pin 5, we haven't changed anything about the operation of the relay, only the source of electrons which we will feed to the solenoid.

Tape, or a crimp dead-end cover to the wire harness. Whatever you prefer just to be sure it doesn't short to ground.

iainw wrote:On an 05 Breva 1100 the wire to cut and take to the battery is pin 3 the yellow wire, and not pin 5 the orange/yellow wire.


Mike @MPHCycles small block:

This issue is well known and very well documented by many owners on this forum and others.
After spending quite some time on a few of them recently I offer these suggestions;
The CARC bikes have the same problem as the small blocks that exhibit this symptom, but a slightly different fix is possible.
The basic issue is a voltage drop on the positive side, from battery to the starter relay. On the bikes I have been measuring, we see as much as a 4.0 volt loss. This obviously makes it hard for the relay deliver the amperage needed to engage the starter solenoid reliably.

The small block needs a power supply relay added in to deliver full 12V to the starter relay supply side.

guzzielec001.jpg

This is simple enough to do by removing the orange wire from the starter relay socket, plugging it to the 85 terminal on the new relay. 86 goes to a GOOD ground. 30 goes to battery positive, 87 goes to the original starter relay in the hole where the orange wire was removed. What this does is use the stock wiring only to close the relay instead of supply the power for the load. This should also help eliminate the starter fuse blowing at random times.

guzzielec003.jpg


Mike @MPHCycles CARC Fix:

On the CARC bikes, we have seen a similar voltage drop in the circuit that feeds the ignition switch (yellow on these bikes). After making sure the plug for the ignition switch, battery terminals and chassis ground are clean and tight, there was still a drop of 2.2 volts by the time the juice gets to the starter relay. It seems there is a splice in the harness (in the area of the harness shown), where the lead from where the alternator is joined to the ignition switch circuit.

guzzielec008.jpg

This circuit is easily "supplemented" by an additional wire, paralleling the circuit from near the fuse box green/red wire to the bike side of the ignition switch connector. At this connector there is an inexplicable size drop in the wire. I dont have pics of the bike after the additional wiring is done for this one.

guzzielec005.jpg


guzzielec006.jpg

It works for me, if you try it on your bike, use common sense regarding materials, routing, fusing etc. If this sounds like more than you are comfortable doing, than don't do it. Use the info to assist the Tech who does it for you.
Todd at
GuzziTech.com
SoCal GuzziTech Power Since 2001!

Image Image
User avatar
GT-Rx
Administrator
 
Posts: 3942
Joined: Wed Jul 01, 2009 5:29 pm
Location: SoCal U.S.A.

Re: Modern "No Crank" Starting issue solution

Postby johnk » Thu Jul 01, 2010 9:23 am

I did a similar thing to my V11 sport and it has solved the problems I had there as well.
Unless everything was absolutely perfect I'd have intermittent starter operation issues.
Since doing this about a year ago it's worked every time.

johnk
johnk
Just got it firing!
 
Posts: 15
Joined: Thu Oct 30, 2008 8:25 am

Re: Modern "No Crank" Starting issue solution

Postby sign216 » Thu Jul 01, 2010 1:49 pm

Todd, thanks for the photos and instructions for the smallblock. This is a modification that I've been planning to do for some time, and it's good to get an different approach.

Joe
sign216
Cruisin' Guzzista
 
Posts: 413
Joined: Sun Jun 14, 2009 6:47 am

Re: Modern "No Crank" Starting issue solution

Postby RJVB » Fri Jul 02, 2010 2:40 am

There's an explanation on the French forum about the starter fuse blowing. This is a 15A fuse, but IIRC it only protects the solenoid (plus a number of other things), and under normal functioning a 15A threshold is largely sufficient. A measured voltage drop is of course caused by a large current draw somewhere in the circuit, and (again IIRC) this can be caused by the solenoid not engaging quickly enough.

Or was it on here that I read about that (can't seem to find the post on the french forum)??! :oops: :oops: :oops:
Norge 1200 GT. Eminence Grise Image
User avatar
RJVB
Moderator
 
Posts: 1948
Joined: Tue Oct 28, 2008 12:55 pm
Location: Paris, France

Re: Modern "No Crank" Starting issue solution

Postby Brian UK » Fri Jul 02, 2010 2:45 pm

You know, I had to do a similar wiring mod in the start relay feed on the V50, and on the SPIII. It seems Guzzi never learn.
I'll do some checks on my Norge.
Brian.
Brian UK
Rockstar Guzzisti
 
Posts: 1047
Joined: Thu Nov 06, 2008 8:00 am
Location: Addlestone, Surrey, UK

Re: Modern "No Crank" Starting issue solution

Postby Mi_ka » Sat Jul 03, 2010 5:37 am

Any schematics with the mods applied?

What do you think? Bad quality or inadequate part & wires or sneak current paths not properly resolved by the designers during developement?
(example: http://www.subaruforester.org/vbulletin/f85/what-happens-when-headlight-fuse-blows-6139/ )
Michail,
a Guzzista at heart
Mi_ka
Cruisin' Guzzista
 
Posts: 451
Joined: Fri May 14, 2010 1:05 pm
Location: Thessaly, Greece

Re: Modern "No Crank" Starting issue solution

Postby baloches » Sat Jul 03, 2010 7:54 am

I've been having this intermittent issue, and have gone through Todd's wiring mod using Carl's great schematics.

My take on it is that the green/red wire is the feed from the alternator back to the battery, and the lack of capacity at that connector and gauge reduction is limiting the ability to recharge the battery, which would seem to be the root of my problem, i.e. no-start at fuel stop after long idle time in traffic with autocomm, xm and gps, high beams etc...

This has happened three times under same conditions, after a good wait the battery would recover enough power to overcome the ECU's low-volt threshold and the bike would fire right up. I have checked the obvious, such as condition of connectors, ground, battery etc.
I have not load-tested my battery, it is possible that it is on it's way out, not having any reserve.

I don't understand the idea that this circuit is improving current to the ignition switch and starter relay, aside from keeping the battery properly charged. Could anybody enlighten me? I have a good understanding of vehicle electrics, working on mobile equipment electrics on a daily basis.
2007 Norge
1986 LeMans IV
2004 Multistrada
Mascouche, Qc.
User avatar
baloches
GT Contributor!
 
Posts: 135
Joined: Mon Feb 09, 2009 4:43 pm

Re: Modern "No Crank" Starting issue solution

Postby Brian UK » Tue Jul 06, 2010 7:04 am

Can anyone see a reason why the yellow feed to the start relay has to go via the ignition switch at all? It seems to me that the easiest cure (on my Norge at least) would be to remove the yellow wire connected to the relay and replace it with a direct connection to battery positive (though preferably via a 15 amp fuse).
This is effectively the same as I did on the V50 and SPIII.

Having said all that, I've just checked voltages on the Norge, and voltage loss from battery positive to the start relay (yellow wire) is 0.25V approx when the ignition is switched on, and 0.75V when actually starting.
This should not cause a problem, and yet I have recently had the "click, no crank" situation, and had the fuse blow before that.
Brian.
Brian UK
Rockstar Guzzisti
 
Posts: 1047
Joined: Thu Nov 06, 2008 8:00 am
Location: Addlestone, Surrey, UK

Re: Modern "No Crank" Starting issue solution

Postby Brian UK » Wed Jul 07, 2010 9:25 am

This circuit is easily "supplemented" by an additional wire, paralleling the circuit from near the fuse box green/red wire to the bike side of the ignition switch connector. At this connector there is an inexplicable size drop in the wire.
This is because the ignition switch harness comes that size, supplied by Zadi or whoever makes them.
In my automotive experience it is very unusual to have the solenoid current going through the ignition switch. In fact I doubt if the switch is really designed to take 20A peak. They normally assume a relay will be used. I just wish I knew why Guzzi insist on doing it this way.
Brian.
Brian UK
Rockstar Guzzisti
 
Posts: 1047
Joined: Thu Nov 06, 2008 8:00 am
Location: Addlestone, Surrey, UK

Re: Modern "No Crank" Starting issue solution

Postby Mi_ka » Wed Jul 07, 2010 9:31 am

Dio mio.. :blink:
Michail,
a Guzzista at heart
Mi_ka
Cruisin' Guzzista
 
Posts: 451
Joined: Fri May 14, 2010 1:05 pm
Location: Thessaly, Greece

Next

Return to CARC

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest